Surround Sound vs Stereo

I recently picked up a new TV for my bedroom.  I ended up with a very nice Sharp 720p 32" LCD.  However, now that I have the new screen, I wanted to upgrade the sound system in my bedroom.

First off, to help understand my bedroom we should go over a few things about this area.  I have a roommate, so it is important to me that my bedroom has all of my creature comforts that I might want somewhere else in the apartment.  This way, if I want to just chill in my room and no annoy people, I have that ability.  That being said, I currently have a six foot couch in my room facing my TV, so think of it like a very small studio apartment.

After I setup my TV, I realized that I much preferred the look of video games on the LCD screen versus the DLP.  However, that is a different store, the result of which means my XBOX 360 and PS3 are now in my bedroom.  When I play video games, I very much enjoy having good audio to go with them, so upgrading my sound beyond the standard built in speakers was a must.

I shopped around for a few different options.  I have an older Dolby Digital 5.1 Sony Receiver, however it is starting to show its age (the remote kind of works).  It was really a coin flip if I was going to use it or replace it.  If i replaced it, I would upgrade the 6.1 Dolby Digital/DTS Yamaha Receiver in the living room.  The options for that got costly quick, so I factored that out.  Now I was down to shopping for Speakers or a Home Theater in a Box (HTIB).

I shopped a few HTIB's in the $300.00 price range.  I wasn't really impressed with what I was seeing outside of an Onkyo setup sold at Circuit City.  My only concern with the Onkyo setup was that it was that the Receiver was only 90% real, in my opinion.  And that really didn't upgrade anything in my opinion.

I moved onto shopping for speaker packages to use with my old Receiver.  While I was impressed with a few packages from Yamaha and JBL, I really didn't want to run wire all over my room.  And when looking at just two bookshelf speakers and a subwoofer the cost started to creep up to levels I didn't want to pay (again, I would upgrade the sub in my living room).

Then I found some Sony Floorstanding speakers at Best Buy.  I picked them up for about $135.00 and was expecting to be unimpressed and return them.  However, now that I have them setup and mostly tuned, I have to say that I am very impressed.  While I have heard better speakers, I can honestly say that I don't miss the surround sound in my small room and that the bass, mids, and highs are sound good.  The fact that they were such a value makes them even better in my opinion.

In closing, I am starting to realize that Surround Sound is a little overrated.  This does not mean that I am swearing off my love of Dolby Digital and DTS, however I am learning its place in my home.  To truly enjoy Surround Sound you need room for the sound to spread out and truly build up the surround effect.  If you have a small room, I would suggest picking up two nice speakers that can accurately reproduce the mid-tones in music.  From that starting point you can start to add more speakers for Surround Sound as you rooms get bigger.

Categories

About This Post

This page contains a single entry by Thomas Wayne posted on October 5, 2007 3:08 PM.

The Wii Turns 10 Months ... yay? was the previous post in tech-shui.com.

The Day the Music Changed is the next post in tech-shui.com.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.